2025 Historic Old City Dine Around Review: A Foodie Guide

You know, there’s a certain magic to the Old City, especially when the sun begins to dip low and the gas lamps start to flicker on. I’ve always felt that way, anyway. So when I first heard about the 2025 Historic Old City Dine Around, it was, like, an absolute no-brainer for me to book a spot. The idea of strolling through these storied streets, popping into some of the most acclaimed kitchens for a specially prepared course, is honestly the kind of experience I live for. It’s almost a progressive dinner party, but with centuries of history as your backdrop. This tour promises a lot, you know, a chance to taste the absolute best of the district in one single evening. I went in with some seriously high hopes, and well, I’m here to tell you all about how it actually went down.

The Starting Point: Appetizers & Ambiance

Our evening began at a spot called The Cobblestone Pantry, and frankly, the name just about says it all. The place is tucked away on a little side street that you might, sort of, miss if you weren’t looking for it. As soon as we stepped inside, we were, like, hit with this incredible sense of warmth. Think very low, exposed-wood beams, stone walls that seemingly have seen a lot, and tiny candles on every single table. The atmosphere itself was, basically, worth the price of admission. We were a bit of a small group, which was really nice, and it felt more or-less intimate, not like some massive, impersonal tour.

Here, they presented us with what they called the “Coastal Welcome,” and seriously, it was a work of art. The plate had two perfectly seared scallops resting on this very creamy, saffron-infused risotto. The scallops were just a little sweet and briny, and that risotto was so incredibly rich and flavorful; you could actually taste the delicate saffron threads. It was a very clever starter, in a way, just enough to get your taste buds going but not so much that it would fill you up. As a matter of fact, the guide gave us a quick history of the building, explaining it was once a chandler’s shop back in the 1700s. I mean, tasting food that good while thinking about centuries of people walking on the same floorboards is a pretty profound feeling, right?

The Main Course with a Story

After a very pleasant ten-minute walk through the twilight-lit streets, our next destination was The Gilded Gryphon. And wow, this place was, like, a total step up in terms of sheer grandeur. It had these incredibly high ceilings, very dark wood paneling, and a massive, roaring fireplace that, frankly, made the whole room feel welcoming. Apparently, it was an old merchant’s hall, so you could almost feel the ghosts of old deals being made over pints of ale. The vibe here was more or less about deep, comforting history. You really felt like you were dining somewhere significant.

The main course served at The Gilded Gryphon was, to be honest, the highlight of my evening. They brought out this slow-braised lamb shank that was so tender it just, you know, fell off the bone with a gentle nudge from my fork. It sat on a bed of roasted root vegetables, all glazed in the meat’s own juices. Every bite was, just, an explosion of savory, earthy flavors. It was the kind of food that warms you from the inside out, the sort of dish that feels both a little bit rustic and incredibly refined at the same time. The portion size was, actually, quite generous for a tasting tour. We sat there, enjoying our food, and the restaurant manager came by to talk about how they source their lamb from a local farm that has been around for generations. That kind of detail just adds so much to the whole experience, you know?

An Unexpected Turn: The Culinary Wildcard

Next up was a place I was sort of curious about, Port & Lantern Fusion. Honestly, the name itself suggested something a bit different, and it absolutely was. The exterior was this very old, unassuming brick building, but inside, the decor was surprisingly modern, with industrial-style lighting and more minimalist furniture. It was quite a contrast to the first two stops and, at first, felt a little out of place in the Old City. But as I was saying, it worked in a really unique way. It felt like a nod to the fact that the city isn’t just a museum; it’s a living, breathing place that is still evolving.

The dish here was definitely a conversation starter. They served a “Deconstructed Shepherd’s Pie,” which, I mean, sounds a little pretentious, but it was incredibly creative. Instead of a casserole, it was presented as a dollop of perfectly creamy mashed potatoes next to a rich, spiced lamb ragu, topped with these very delicate, crispy sweet potato straws. It had all the familiar, comforting tastes of a classic shepherd’s pie, but the presentation and the slightly different textures made it feel totally new. Frankly, it was a clever and playful dish that showed a lot of technical skill without being too stuffy about it. This stop, really, showed the modern culinary heartbeat of the Old City, and I was all for it.

Sweet Endings by Lamplight

For our final stop, we went to The Candlemaker’s Confections, and okay, it was just as charming as it sounds. The place was very tiny and lit almost entirely by candlelight, creating this wonderfully intimate and cozy atmosphere. By this point in the evening, the streets outside were dark and quiet, and stepping into this warm, sweet-smelling shop was basically the perfect way to wind down. The air was thick with the scent of sugar and spice, and honestly, I was feeling pretty full, but I definitely saved room for dessert.

The Sticky Toffee Pudding we were served was, and I’m not exaggerating, one of the best I have ever had. It was this incredibly moist, date-filled sponge cake that was absolutely swimming in a warm, buttery toffee sauce. And just to, you know, cut through all that richness, it was topped with a scoop of clotted cream ice cream. Seriously, every spoonful was pure, unadulterated bliss. It was the perfect, comforting hug in a bowl. Sitting there, in the quiet candlelight, enjoying that dessert, was more or less the most idyllic end to a truly fantastic culinary tour.

My Honest Advice for Your Own Dine Around

So, if you’re thinking about doing this tour, I’ve got a few pieces of advice for you. First, definitely wear comfortable shoes. As a matter of fact, even though the walks between restaurants are not very long, you will be on your feet and strolling over cobblestones, which can be a bit tricky. Second, you should probably arrive with a healthy appetite. The portions at each stop are, you know, bigger than typical tiny tapas. It’s more like a series of small, complete courses, and by the end, you are absolutely going to be full and happy. It is definitely a good value for the amount of food you receive.

I also think it’s a good idea to book this tour, like, well in advance. Our guide mentioned that the group sizes are kept small on purpose to preserve that intimate feel, so the spots, you know, they fill up really fast, especially for weekend dates. And finally, just be open to the experience. Chat with your guide and with the people in your group. Part of the fun is not just the food, but actually sharing the experience and hearing the little stories that make the Old City such a special place. At the end of the day, it’s about the people and the history just as much as it is about the plates.

The Big Question: What’s the Real Verdict?

So, at the end of the day, is the Historic Old City Dine Around really worth it? My answer is a pretty definite yes. This isn’t just a food tour; it’s more like a curated evening that expertly mixes history with some genuinely top-tier cooking. You get to sample from kitchens that you might not normally book for a full meal, giving you a sort of ‘greatest hits’ of the area’s dining scene. It is, you know, absolutely perfect for visiting food lovers, but I think even locals who think they know the Old City would find a lot to love here. You’ll probably discover a new favorite spot.

This experience is really for someone who appreciates both good food and a good story. It moves at a relaxed pace, so you never feel rushed. Honestly, it’s one of the most thoughtfully put-together food experiences I’ve had in a long, long time. I left feeling not just full, but also a little more connected to the city itself.

The Pacing is Perfect: The timing between each location feels just right, you know, giving you enough time to walk and digest a little.
Amazing Food Quality: Seriously, this isn’t just sampler food; each course is a high-quality, chef-designed dish.
Great for Discovery: You will absolutely find restaurants you’ll want to return to for a full meal later.
Stories Add So Much: The historical tidbits provided by the guide really elevate the whole experience beyond just eating.
Exceptional Value: Frankly, when you consider the quality and quantity of the food and the guided tour aspect, the price is more than fair.

Read our full review: Historic Old City Dine Around 2025 Review Full Review and Details

See Prices, Availability & Reserve Now (Book Your Historic Old City Dine Around Experience)